《分歧者》第一册的家长评论

我喜欢书中的人物和故事，在一周内读完了整个系列!我最喜欢的角色是特丽丝，我喜欢她和老四的浪漫。其他人应该知道，影片中有相当数量的暴力和枪击事件，以及关于性的讨论，但这并没有压倒主要情节。要注意的是，这个系列并没有一个非常愉快的结局(我哭了，把书扔到了墙上)，但我仍然喜欢它。五星，绝对推荐给像我一样喜欢反乌托邦故事的人!

《分歧者》讲述的是16岁的特丽丝生活在一个反乌托邦的未来。我在高中时读过这本书，非常喜欢!当我10岁的女儿让我读的时候，我说我先读。我不记得什么糟糕的事，我只是想确认一下。但比我想象的要多得多。我决定等几年再让女儿读这本书。以下是我的评论:暴力:《无畏》的开始阶段包括跳下火车，一个女孩抓住火车边缘尖叫求救，这样她就不会摔死(有点令人不安，但不是真的担心)。也有许多为印心而战。彼得和特丽丝吵了一架，场面很难看，但没有描述。有人把特丽丝吊在栏杆上袭击她。 Tris is forced to face her worst fears in a mental test. And towards the end, an important character is killed. As is Natalie. Language: Damn, hell, piss, ass, and sh*t are used. Drinking, drugs, and smoking: Tobias gets drunk. Consumerism: none. Sex: This is my main concern. It starts out okay, but the end is a little iffy. Tris and Tobias hold hands and kiss. A lot. One of Tris’s fears is about Tobias’s expectations for sex (pretty described). She has a panic attack about it. Other characters kiss.

嗨,伙计们!我教七年级。我们班选择在反乌托邦单元读这本书。我非常怀疑。这本书是非凡的。我认为家长和老师应该知道一些警告。我对这本书的评价:暴力:“暴力”，“情节”，“如果”，“如果”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”，“暴力”

我是一个温和的反乌托邦迷，所以每当我听说《分歧者》时，我都非常兴奋。一个反乌托邦的世界，每个人都被基于美德的派系划分?一个强大的女性主角?帮我报名吧!是的，事实上，这是一本非常好的读物。但是我不能让自己给这本书的评分超过三颗星，我会列出我的理由。首先是角色:Tris Prior: 4.5星。我爱她。她很坚强，但没有牺牲她的女性气质，这一点我非常喜欢她。她喜欢漂亮的衣服、漂亮的妆容和女孩的谈话，但她完全可以像母狮一样踢屁股和战斗，这是现代作家似乎错过的东西。他们认为，为了证明一个女性角色是坚强的，他们必须剥去所有的女性气质。 That is absolutely not true, if anything, it makes me respect the characters all the more, because they can be feminine but fierce. Determined but delicate. Strong but sweet, and it makes them all the tougher. Rants aside, I loved her more than I have loved a character in a long, long while. She’s just amazing. Veronica Roth did such an awesome job with her character, and I completely, totally applaud her for her wonderful female lead. Tobias Eaton: 3. 8 stars. I liked Tobias, but I didn’t love Tobias. He’s much, MUCH better than, say, Gale Hawthorne or Peeta Mellark or Teresa or Brenda, four not-so-awesome love interests, but I guess that compared to Tris, his character seems a bit weak. But, then again, I’m pretty sure any literary character would seem like a sissy compared to Tris, even the famed Katniss Everdeen. But back to Tobias: His character fits the role of the moody-broody-mysterious-bad-boy love interest to a tee, and that’s why I wasn’t overly impressed with his character. Veronica Roth clearly has the talent to create amazing characters, so I feel like… She could’ve done better with Tobias. He fits into a category a little too easily for my liking. All opinions aside, I know that people love Tobias, so I will stop ranting and get on with the rest of the characters. Christina: 4 stars. Very likable character, I loved that she is not one of what I not-so-fondly call the “factioned”. I will get to that later. I honestly just like Christina, I don’t have anything else to say about her character. Will: 3 stars. I like Will’s character, buuuuuuut we don’t see him too much. So I do like this character, but I don’t know enough to say that I love his character. Al: 3 stars. I loved Al at the beginning, but after that I hated him. Tori: 4 stars: I really like her, that’s about all I have to say about her. Natalie Prior: 5 stars. Great role model-mother. Tris’s dad: 4 stars. Very nice touch to the series. Peter: 2 stars. I have a love-hate relationship with this character. I guess that you could say that I love to hate him. Caleb Prior: 3 stars. An ok character. Jeanine Matthews: 2 stars. Errrmmm, I don’t really like this villain. She’s not delightfully evil-ish enough for me. Relationships (ships): Trisbias (Tris/Tobias): 3 stars. They fall into a category I call the almost-shippables. That means that I don’t ship them, but I almost could’ve. The things I liked about their relationship were that there wasn’t any unnecessary drama. Everything was refreshingly straightforward. However, their chemistry wasn’t good enough for me to ship them. Will/Christina (Willtina? Willstina?): 3 stars. Cute, not noteworthy. Note: Now I’m going to list the main reason that I didn’t rate Divergent at four stars: The factioned. It feels like Veronica Roth said something like this while writing this book, “Oh, if I have a faction that focuses on intelligence, then they need to think that wearing glasses makes you look smarter and all say, “That couldn’t happen, that’s illogical!” All the time! And if I have a brave faction, they need to think that jumping off of trains and getting tattoos and piercings makes you courageous!” Those things don’t make you brave or intelligent, and that is one of the points of this series. But the point would’ve come across better had some of the characters not been so one-dimensional. Now, since I’ve bored you with this long review, I’ll only say one more thing. Divergent is good. A bit weak at times, but good. And if you’re a fan of dystopian societies, you’ll love it. ;)

我认为这本书应该被禁止给任何孩子看，也不应该被允许在学校作为作业分发。在这个暴力横行的时代，我们不需要年轻人阅读生动的攻击、暴力、仇恨、纹身、穿孔和仇恨，只是为了在最后传达一个信息。这本书非常令人不安，父母们认为这本书是5颗星，这让我明白了这个世界现2022卡塔尔世界杯队伍在是错误的一个重要原因。

是的，这是我读过的最好的书之一，非常棒，但是里面有一些性的场景，所以如果你的孩子11岁，我认为他们可以接受像这样更成熟的书，这很棒，11岁的孩子在学校谈论这种类型的东西，但这是一个很棒的故事，关于一个与所有人都不同的人，她必须保守秘密，她必须找到自己是谁。所以这对青少年吸毒很有好处，但除此之外也没那么糟糕(偶尔会骂人)所以不要忍住让你的孩子读这篇文章，这很好，你甚至可以自己读:)

我觉得其他的评论没有给这部电影一个公平的机会。是的，这里有暴力。是的，有提到自杀，但这些都是青少年正在经历的事情!老实说，我们的世界变化太大了，现在的青少年比20年前要面对更多的事情!你们不要再这么关心这件事了。青少年已经知道喝酒是什么，如果你正确地教育他们，他们就会知道这不是一件好事!如果你因为酗酒或暴力而不让你十几岁和十几岁的孩子读这本书，我问你你害怕什么?他们会开始喝酒吗?他们会打架吗?一本书不会说服他们这么做! If your kid is that easly influenced, then its your parenting thats the problem. If you preventing your kid from reading Divergent because they are not mature enough in your opoion, then you really need to step back and reexamine your family. I guarantee your kid isn't as inncoent as you think. This book addresses all the issuses in the world, through a distopia. School shootings are something that might happen at your kids school, you have no way to prevent it. Why not prepare them and tell them what to do if it ever happens, rather than shield them from the possibility? When they turn 18, they are an adult. You cannot protect them any longer. They will have access to the whole world, but not understand how to use it, because you hide them. Then you have failed as a parent because you have not set them up for success. Stop hovering over your kid. Let them read the damn book.

这是一本很棒的书!这部电影有一个非常励志的主角，非常情绪化，而且有点不合适……但我个人认为任何一个成熟的11岁以上的孩子都会喜欢它。

我觉得这很神奇。它和《饥饿游戏》一样好，但比《迷宫跑者》好一点。它确实有很多死亡，有好有坏，还有特丽丝和小四私下亲热/接吻。游戏中有血腥的摔跤、恐惧模拟和枪战等场景，但它们通常都没有那么血腥或暴力。

就我个人而言，我认为这本书对我12岁的女儿来说会很好，但她告诉我，书中有一些关于两个主要人物(比阿特丽斯和托拜厄斯)关系的细节，这是不必要的。比如他们在火车上亲热。