《黑天鹅》的家长评论

暴力:4/5-自残。血腥真实的伤害细节。脚受伤，指甲断了。一个女人用玻璃捅另一个女人，血不多，但有。用开信刀捅人，很令人不安。性的威胁。性:4/5-相当生动的舔阴(口交)，但没有裸体。激烈的亲吻。性参考。性的威胁。 Language 4/5- Frequent f**k, shit, damn, slut and whore. Drinking smoking drugs 4/5- Women get high on unspecified drug. Drinking. Role models 0/5- Nina is a dangerous unstable character and the people around her don't help. Her mother is controlling. Her director is a creep. Excellent film, Natalie Portman steals the show.

有来自孩子们的评论说，它很好，没有那么糟糕。我不同意。然而，对于成熟的观众来说，这应该是可以接受的，我理解所有人都不会在同一年龄成熟。这部电影涵盖了情感/精神虐待、抑郁、自残等沉重的话题。它很暴力，而且有点令人不安。影片中还描绘了吸毒的场景，以及其他角色以性的方式触摸主角身体的一些场景。片中有一场性爱戏。这是一部美丽而令人惊叹的电影，它是一部真正的艺术作品。讲述了一个女孩为了得到一个重要角色不惜一切代价的故事。然而，这部电影绝对不适合在孩子们面前看。

我今年24岁，很容易被令人不安的内容所影响。我对恐怖的事不太在行。因为这不是传统的恐怖片，而且我听说它有多神奇，所以我决定尝试一下。我打算把它关掉，如果它开始打扰我在任何时候。我也曾经是一个足尖舞者，所以我很兴奋地看到一部关于芭蕾的电影。许多评论都说这部电影“比任何恐怖电影都可怕”，这让我多年都不敢看，但我真的找不到比这更离谱的了。这是一出激烈的戏剧。首先，这部电影太不可思议了。48小时内我看了两遍。从来没有一部电影能在如此原始而美丽的杰作中捕捉到完美主义。 The most disturbing thing about the movie to me is the ballet teacher taking advantage of his student in a couple of brief, clothed handsy scenes. That kind of stuff makes my stomach turn, but it wasn't graphic and went by quickly on screen. Many reviews stated that there is graphic expression of mental illness (self harm / purging), but this content is more alluded to than seen blatantly on camera. I was worried about that, because I find that to be too hard to watch, but it was subtle and implied. I will say this. The film is about a young woman with extreme perfectionism. It drives her to the breaking point, and she starts to mix reality with hallucination. She develops paranoia and starts to think this other girl is out to get her, but really she is just out to get herself and doesn't understand it's coming from within. Probably the most disturbing thing about the film that didn't bother me but seems to bother others is how you watch this seemingly healthy young adult drive herself insane. Most perfectionists probably can relate to some degree, but those who have never seen that stream of consciousness up close may find that dark side of human nature to be creepy. There is an oral sex scene between two women, but no nudity due to the camera angle. Also brief, nudity-free masturbation. Nothing that would shock anyone in their mid teens. Spoiler alert: The movie ends with the lead character stabbing herself after she performs the ballet role perfectly. It represents her killing the old version of herself (her White Swan side), but in doing so, she is also killing her actual self. This is due to the perfectionism for the ballet role she is playing (which quite literally, is Swan Lake where she plays the White Swan and Black Swan, having to perform two different versions of herself). The other thing that was off putting about the film is the mother/daughter relationship. The 28 year old lead character lives with her very controlling mother in a bedroom fit for a 10 year old. There are no boundaries and the lead character is treated like she is a little girl, which is weird to watch. This all leads up to the main character hitting her breaking point and letting loose, declaring her adulthood. This does entail her taking ecstasy at a club and getting drunk for the first time. Again, nothing that will shock your teen, but it would be too much for a child to understand. If you are trying to decide if you should let your child watch this, I would say 15 and up seems appropriate. If they are 15-18, have an open dialogue with them about what they see. It's important to talk about mental illness at that age, and the lead character does come of age throughout the course of the film. You can use it to discuss perfectionism and the dangers of it with your teen. It's important to be their sounding board. My immediate thought when watching was "Wow, this would have been great for 15 year old me to watch and learn from." If I watched this as a teen, I would have felt more understood and open to discussing my perfectionistic pressures. The movie is EXCELLENT and I highly recommend it. About to go watch it a third time (yes, it's THAT good).

这是一部恐怖电影。它可能没有跳跃恐惧、血腥或怪物，但它有其他一切。不适合那些无法接受压倒性电影的人(这让我从头到尾都很焦虑)。片中有几场性爱戏。两个自慰场景和一个WLW性爱场景。后者仍然是一个场景，但没有裸体展示，有一个转折，改变了之后的叙事。

娜塔莉·波特曼将这位痴迷的艺术家演绎得如此精彩。电影太好了。十分之一的人都应该看

这是一部伟大的电影，但这不是给孩子看的，有很多性场景，包括自慰，一个男人触摸一个女人的乳房和阴道(穿着衣服)，还有一个女同性恋的性爱场景，娜塔莉·波特曼做了一个很好的工作推荐，如果成熟/成年人/青少年接近成年

妮娜·塞耶斯是个彻头彻尾的悲剧女主角。我这么说的意思是，除了她有一个导致她堕落的缺点之外，她必须体面地接受这一点，我们，观众，不应该期望对结局感到惊讶;这通常是可以预测的。话虽如此，我们必须知道阿罗诺夫斯基的任务是让电影充满恐惧和恐怖的氛围，以预示悲剧的结局，同时尽可能地挑战极限，以使一切看起来都是原创的，因此是意想不到的。第一件事实际上是达伦·阿罗诺夫斯基所擅长的。在《黑天鹅》中，阿罗诺夫斯基创造了一种噩梦般的超现实主义氛围;使用了一些他在电影中使用过的最有效的，如果不是最暴力的，生动的血腥画面，以及几乎和他在《梦的安魂曲》中一样完美的声音，只是这次不仅仅是为了扰乱，而且是为了恐吓和恐吓。在此过程中，阿罗诺夫斯基不仅为妮娜不可避免的可怕的堕落埋下了伏笔，还让我们感受到了妮娜的痛苦，就好像我们变成了她一样;阿罗诺夫斯基做了我的羽毛皮肤爬行!可惜的是，《黑天鹅》的视觉意象缺乏创造力。 Most of the symbolic imagery I felt that they are quite familiar, and that I had seen many times before. That said, the visceral and bold direction of Aronofsky made up for that with genuine intensity. The vague and mysterious nature of the characters and their actions adds up to the uniqueness of the movie, especially as they don't tarnish the drama, nor reject the logic for the sake of surrealism. I enjoyed interpreting the characters' motives, actions, and even purposes and roles in the story. The way they are represented can feel a bit messy sometimes, though. I think that what made me believe that the movie is a bit convoluted for its own good, and that Aronofsky tried too hard to give us as many reasons as he could to persuade us that Nina deserves her tragic fate while Nina's "hamartia" is crystal clear from hundred miles away in a most play-like way. The performances are all truly outstanding. As for Natalie Portman, she delivered what is indisputably her fantastic career's best performance; she was simply Perfect! (8.5/10)

这是一部令人难以置信且充满智慧的电影，尽管我对达伦·阿罗诺夫斯基的期望并不低。娜塔莉·波特曼(Natalie Portman)在《天鹅湖》(Swan Lake)中的主角角色让她在精神上和身体上都受到了越来越多的折磨，她需要探索自己的阴暗面。正如许多人所说，女同性恋的性爱场面相当露骨，但对情节来说是必要的。我不记得在这部电影中除了女人穿胸罩和内裤之外看到过任何裸体，但也许我错过了。脏话在r级电影中很常见，偶尔会有f*ck, sh*t等。毒品的使用仅限于吸烟，喝酒，以及在非积极的光线下显示的摇头丸场景，并且不建议使用它。然而，电影中的暴力是非常令人震惊的，包括(剧透)她在精神上刺伤莉莉，但在身体上刺伤自己的场景。这部电影非常令人不安，越来越多地关注妮娜如何不断地在身体和精神上伤害自己，以达到完美，而她(剧透)最后的死亡显示了她在心理上受到了多大的伤害。她的遗言也证明了这一点。总的来说，这是一部伟大的电影，尽管公然暴力、黑暗、令人不安和性。 Probably best for teens 15 and up.

这部电影讲的是芭蕾舞界的压力。15岁以下青少年不宜观看。这部电影有非常激烈的场景，一些性爱场景非常长，尤其是两个女人之间的，还有毒品。我很喜欢这部电影，因为它的情节和黑暗沉重的气氛。我把这部电影推荐给15岁左右的成年人，也推荐给年龄更大的人。