父母和孩子评论

窈窕淑女

窈窕淑女形象海报
我们的审查
9岁或以上

基于8父评论

10岁+

非常,非常失望。

这部电影并不是完全准确的描述。当然是一个恶棍;它只是讽刺,他应该是英雄。亨利•希金斯绝对是卑鄙的人,几乎没有可取之处的。当然他帮助伊丽莎,一个非常有限的方式,但他确实没有利他主义和慷慨。这个想法,他“学习很多关于女性,以及对肤浅的外表与内在美”是完全错误的。他似乎没有弧,据我告诉他不可以学习任何课程的电影。没有,不幸的是,伊丽莎。奥黛丽·赫本是美好的,但性格是我希望我的女儿没有证人。虽然她是活跃的,在现实中她似乎没有自尊。 SPOILER: Her return to Higgins at the end of the film is one of the most tragic endings I've ever seen.
3人发现这有帮助。
10岁+

恶劣!为什么这是排名前十的家庭电影名单上吗?

官方的常识媒体评论真的让我2022世界杯16强预测失望。伊丽莎发展综合症女性爱上一个俘虏者,和希金斯教授是出言不逊。名字他在伊莉莎索具包括“无耻的贱妇”,“冒昧的昆虫”和“流浪儿”。He doesn't respect her as a person at all, but treats her as a throwaway object that he USES to win a bet. About the language, it's not just that there are a good number of "damns" and "for God's sakes"; Higgins actually says "Damn you!" to Eliza, as well as "you look like the very devil." He sings a song of pure, ridiculous misogyny called "Why can't a woman be more like a man?" I felt very uncomfortable for my daughter and son to be exposed to words such as: "...Women are irrational, that's all there is to that! Their heads are full of cotton, hay, and rags. They're nothing but exasperating, irritating, vacillating, calculating, agitating, maddening and infuriating hags! " In the one song in which Eliza seems to have grown a spine, ("The world will go on without you"), Prof. Higgins keeps calling her a "hussy." The messages about class are not very helpful. Although it is a good lesson that you can uplift the way you present yourself by speaking properly, the other message is that Eliza can pass for high class because she's beautiful and thin. Yuck - that's lookism. Not that I'm a big fan of class divisions, but at that time I believe one of the markers of class was education. Children of nobility would have read and discussed Shakespeare, Homer, and Virgil with their tutors, as well as learning languages and studying music. But culture and education don't figure in to Eliza's training at all. What a missed opportunity to give a positive message! It would have added a lot to the story if Higgins had exposed Eliza to some literature, which might have touched and enlightened her soul, and perhaps given her an appetite for more. The drinking scene is much more than a "shot" of a bridegroom heading to his wedding. It's actually a whole musical number set in a pub, and and it makes drinking look pretty darn fun, and an aid to singing and dancing. He gets so irresponsibly drunk that he has to count on other people to get him to his own wedding. They literally carry him away, still singing. Is there a subtle message there that alcohol is fun and harmless, and it's okay to marry alcoholics? Although there are no bedroom scenes, or indeed, kisses; it is extremely troubling that Eliza seems to "fall in love" with Higgins and comes back to him at the end. It's not love, it's abused woman syndrome portrayed as a happy ending. Steer clear!

这个标题有:

过多的饮酒/药品/吸烟
2人发现这有帮助。
14岁+

过时的性别价值观

这是一个有趣的电影,作为成年人,我们可以把它当作一个时间胶囊,惊奇地发现,有多少世界已经变了,但我想它会让孩子们难以理解,男人不应该对待女人的方式过亨利希金斯对伊丽莎闲散的人。我想可能这可能是观察并分析了作为一个性别研究类的一部分。看完“窈窕淑女”我震惊地看到高评级为正面消息和榜样。
1人发现这有帮助。
7岁或以上

一个非常有趣的电影

表演的很好,大部分的歌曲都很棒,都很愉快。我绝对讨厌的唯一的事就是结局。对不起,不能他们一直在伊莉莎的结局,最终希金斯不起来?对不起,这部电影并没有使他们工作作为夫妻。

这个标题有:

教育价值
伟大的消息
伟大的榜样
太多的咒骂
过多的饮酒/药品/吸烟
1人发现这有帮助。
9岁或以上

令人愉快的音乐!

我们爱它。这出来一年之后我们其他最喜爱的音乐:Mary Poppins。那些日子……结局有点奇怪,我讨厌她回到他毕竟,无稽之谈。但我们可以原谅,那些愉快的歌曲和服装!

这个标题有:

伟大的消息
11岁+

Pre-watching建议但总体惊人。

就我个人而言,这是一个美丽的电影,即使是我的最爱。我知道一些话题和场景涉及语言和礼仪一般来说可能有点关于为父母,但只要孩子明白窈窕淑女是一个非常古老的电影从一代之前,希金斯的行为特征,例如,不应该被复制在现实生活中,尤其是对女孩子。2022卡塔尔世界杯队伍它可以性别歧视,这是东西,但试着理解这部电影拍摄期间,几乎大多数电影至少有同样的想法或类似的东西。建议避免某些不必要的想法是尝试看电影在不同的光:希金斯的行为那么固执和粗鲁地礼貌的同时抱怨伊丽莎可以被看作是一种讽刺的喜剧。这样可以看到,绝不是电影促进任何类型的性别歧视,至少在我看来。如果你是这样认为的,试着把它变成一个学习的经验。无论如何,注意,我推荐它。一个真正的经典。
5岁+

棒在会话视图

对成年人来说,这部电影可能不会太长。但对年幼的孩子来说,也许把它分成两个/三个经过。我爱只是几乎一切…几个问题点对我但对一个老电影,它是最好的,在我看来。我表达了我的观点在这个问题上进一步:所有things.blogspot.com的整个过程

这个标题有:

教育价值
7岁或以上